Jake Harper
The Marx Brothers' 1929 film, The Cocoanuts, features a comedy routine that has become a touchstone scene for fans. In the scene, Groucho and Chico are discussing a map, and Groucho mentions a viaduct between the mainland and a peninsula. Chico, playing an immigrant with poor English skills, replies Why a duck?. This exchange leads to a long back-and-forth between the two characters, with Chico responding with lines like Why a no chicken? and I catch ona why a horse. The duck became a running gag throughout the Marx Brothers' career, with Groucho's signature walk being called the duck walk.
| Characteristics | Values |
|---|---|
| Year | 1929 |
| Movie | The Cocoanuts |
| Genre | Comedy, Musical, Romance |
| IMDb Rating | 6.8 |
| Starring | Groucho Marx, Chico Marx, Harpo Marx, Zeppo Marx, Margaret Dumont, Basil Ruysdael, Oscar Shaw, Mary Eaton, Kay Francis |
| Plot | The Marx Brothers run a hotel, auction off some land, thwart a jewel robbery, and engage in their usual antics during the Florida land boom |
| "Why a Duck?" Scene | Groucho and Chico discuss a map, with Chico playing an immigrant with poor English skills. Chico's "Why a duck?" line leads to a long back-and-forth with Groucho, becoming a touchstone for Marx Brothers fans |
| Significance | The duck becomes a running gag, with Groucho's signature walk called "the duck walk" and a stuffed duck resembling Groucho used in his TV show "You Bet Your Life" |
Explore related products
![The Marx Brothers Silver Screen Collection (The Cocoanuts / Animal Crackers / Monkey Business / Horse Feathers / Duck Soup) [Blu-ray]](https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/91RtKeoi2ZL._AC_UY218_.jpg)
What You'll Learn
The Marx Brothers' comedy style
Their comedy style is also physical, with Harpo's harp playing and gurning providing a contrast to Groucho and Chico's linguistic acrobatics. Chico's character in The Cocoanuts, for example, is that of an immigrant with poor English skills, which sets up the “Why a duck?” scene, a touchstone for Marx Brothers fans. This scene involves a back-and-forth exchange with Groucho, in which Chico responds to Groucho's mention of a "viaduct" with "Why a duck?", "Why a no chicken?", and so on. The scene is a play on words, with Chico's character misunderstanding Groucho's use of the word "viaduct".
Mastering the Chicken Peck: Fortnite's Secret Move
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The Cocoanuts scene
The Marx Brothers' first film, The Cocoanuts (1929), is a comedy musical romance. It was shot at the Paramount Astoria studio in Queens, New York, and features Broadway performers in the cast. The film is set in the swampy resort town of Coconut Beach, Florida, during the land boom. The Marx Brothers run a hotel, auction off land, and thwart a jewel robbery.
In one scene, Mr. Hammer (Groucho) is complaining to Chico about his partner, Harpo, and his behaviour. He then makes a proposal to Chico:
> Come over here, I want to see you... Now listen to me, I'm not gonna have that red-headed fellow running around in the lobby. If you wanna keep him up in your room, you'll have to keep him in a trap. [...] Now, these lots cost me nine-thousand dollars and I'm gonna let you have 'em for fifteen, because I like you.
Later, Hammer shows Chico a map and points out the road leading out of Cocoanut Manor and a viaduct leading to the mainland. Chico, playing an immigrant with poor English skills, replies, "Why a duck?" This exchange leads into a long routine with Chico responding, "Why a no chicken?", "I catch ona why a horse", and so on.
The "Why a Duck?" scene is a touchstone for Marx Brothers fans and the duck becomes a running gag throughout their careers.
Why 'White Chicks 2' Never Happened
You may want to see also
Explore related products
Duck as a silly animal
The Marx Brothers' 1929 film, The Cocoanuts, features a comedy routine that centres on the question "Why a duck?". In the scene, Groucho and Chico are discussing a map, and Groucho mentions a viaduct between the mainland and a peninsula. Chico, playing an immigrant with poor English skills, replies "Why a duck?". This exchange leads to a back-and-forth between the two characters, with Chico asking, "Why a no chicken?" and Groucho responding, "I don't know why a no chicken; I'm a stranger here myself."
The "Why a duck?" routine became a touchstone for Marx Brothers fans, with the duck becoming a running gag throughout their careers. When asked why a duck was chosen for the gag, Groucho reportedly answered, "because a duck is such a silly animal". This sentiment is reflected in the absurd and light-hearted nature of the "Why a duck?" routine, which relies on wordplay and comedic misunderstandings.
The duck's reputation as a silly animal is further reinforced by its association with the Marx Brothers' brand of comedy, which often involved grifting, hustling, and satirical commentary on society. Ducks also have unique characteristics that may contribute to their perception as silly. For example, they are known for their waddling walk, their distinctive quacking sound, and their tendency to stick their heads under water when feeding, which is how the animal got its name.
In addition to their physical characteristics and behaviour, ducks have also been portrayed in popular culture as silly or comedic relief in various contexts. For example, in the Marx Brothers' film Horse Feathers (1932), ducks are the only animals that perform lines in the song "Everyone Says I Love You". Furthermore, their film Duck Soup (1933) features the brothers at their satirical best, despite the absence of any ducks or soup in the film beyond the title sequence.
Overall, the Marx Brothers' comedy routine "Why a duck?" solidified the duck's reputation as a silly animal in popular culture. Through their comedic genius, the Marx Brothers highlighted the absurd and humorous aspects of ducks, creating a lasting association between the animal and silliness.
Knorr Chicken Bullion: What's in the Mix?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The duck walk
"Why a Duck?" is a comedy routine featured in the Marx Brothers' first film, The Cocoanuts (1929). The scene involves Groucho and Chico discussing a map, on which Groucho points out a viaduct between the mainland and a peninsula. Chico, playing an immigrant with poor English skills, replies "Why a duck?". This exchange leads to a long back-and-forth with Chico, who continues with "Why a no chicken?", "Why a horse", and so on. This scene is considered a touchstone for Marx Brothers fans, with the duck becoming a running gag throughout their careers.
Groucho's signature walk was called "the duck walk". On his television program, "You Bet Your Life", a stuffed duck resembling Groucho would drop from the ceiling to give contestants money if they said the day's secret word.
The "Why a Duck?" scene is also referred to as the "Viaduct/Why A Duck" routine, highlighting the connection between the duck and the viaduct in the scene. The duck walk, therefore, can be interpreted as a reference to the scene, with Groucho's walk being likened to a duck waddling or strutting like a duck.
In conclusion, "the duck walk" is a reference to Groucho Marx's signature walk and the famous "Why a Duck?" scene from The Cocoanuts. The scene involves a discussion about a viaduct and a duck, with Chico's confused responses creating a comedic exchange. The duck walk embodies the humour and absurdity of the Marx Brothers' comedy style, where absurdity reigns over the corrupt and pure alike.
Panda Express Orange Chicken: How Many Pieces?
You may want to see also
Explore related products
The duck gag
"Why a Duck?" is a comedy routine featured in the Marx Brothers' first film, The Cocoanuts (1929). In the scene, Mr. Hammer (Groucho) is complaining to Chico about his partner (Harpo) and makes him an interesting proposal. Hammer then shifts the conversation to a map, pointing out the presence of a viaduct between the mainland and a peninsula. Chico, who is playing the role of an immigrant with poor English skills, replies, "Why a duck?". This exchange leads to a long back-and-forth with Chico responding with "Why a no chicken?", "I catch ona why a horse", and so on. The "duck gag" became a touchstone for Marx Brothers fans and a running gag throughout their careers.
The "Why a Duck?" scene is a classic example of the Marx Brothers' antic wordplay, with Groucho and Chico juggling words with brutal honesty and lightning-fast wit. The scene also showcases the unique dynamic between the brothers, with Chico's character playing along with Groucho's absurd propositions, and Harpo's sudden calm harp solo adding a layer of unexpected lyricism.
The "duck gag" has been analysed and celebrated by fans and critics alike, with some suggesting that it reveals the automatic nature of speech and societal absurdity. The scene also highlights the Marx Brothers' ability to blend comedy with social commentary, as they present a world where society is unjust because it is crazy, rather than evil.
The "Why a Duck?" routine became so iconic that it inspired the title of their next film, "Duck Soup" (1933), and ducks even performed lines in their subsequent film "Everyone Says I Love You" (1932). Groucho himself perpetuated the gag, naming his signature walk "the duck walk", and featuring a stuffed duck on his television program "You Bet Your Life".
The "Why a Duck?" gag in "The Cocoanuts" is a testament to the Marx Brothers' comedic genius, and their ability to create hilarious and memorable scenes that have stood the test of time.
Chicken Feet for Small Dogs: Safe or Not?
You may want to see also
Frequently asked questions
It is a reference to a comedy routine in the Marx Brothers' 1929 movie, "The Cocoanuts".
Mr. Hammer (Groucho) shows Chico a map and mentions a viaduct between the mainland and a peninsula. Chico, playing an immigrant with poor English skills, replies, "Why a duck?". This leads to Chico's iconic lines, "Why a no chicken?", "I catch ona why a horse", and so on.
Groucho Marx reportedly said that a duck was chosen because it is "such a silly animal".
"Why a Duck" is considered a touchstone scene for fans of the Marx Brothers. The duck became a running gag throughout their careers. Groucho's signature walk was called "the duck walk", and a stuffed duck resembling Groucho appeared on his TV show "You Bet Your Life".
The Marx Brothers run a hotel, auction off land, and thwart a jewel robbery during the Florida land boom. The film is a romantic musical comedy and is considered the earliest definitive refutation of the idea that the Golden Age of movie comedies ended with the arrival of sound.
