Uk's Annual Killing Of Male Chicks: A Bloody Business

In the UK, 29 to 40 million male chicks are culled annually. This is done because male chicks cannot lay eggs and are not suitable for meat production. The most common methods of culling are maceration and gassing. While France and Germany have introduced bans on chick culling, the UK continues to slaughter male chicks, with retailers blocking moves to end this practice.

Male chicks are killed because they are deemed redundant to the egg-laying industry

Male chicks are killed because they are considered redundant to the egg-laying industry. Male chicks cannot lay eggs, and they are not the same breed of chicken used for meat. As a result, these chicks are deemed worthless by the egg industry and are killed. This practice, known as chick culling, occurs in all industrialised egg production, whether free-range, organic, or battery cage. Worldwide, around 7 billion male chicks are culled each year in the egg industry. In the United States alone, an average of 8.5 billion male chicks are culled annually, with around 30,000 freshly hatched chicks being killed every hour.

In the UK, it is estimated that 30 to 40 million male chicks are culled annually. The majority of these chicks are killed using an inert gas, such as argon, although maceration is also permitted. Maceration involves transferring the male chicks to a machine called a grinder, where they are killed by "shredding". While some consider maceration to be humane, as it is instant and painless, others argue that it is unethical and raises welfare issues.

The industrial-scale culling of male chicks is a common practice around the world, with 330 million males slaughtered in Europe each year, 29 million of which are in the UK. However, there is societal opposition to chick culling due to animal welfare concerns. Scientists have developed technologies to determine the sexes of chicks while they are still in their eggs, and some countries have taken steps to eliminate the practice of chick culling entirely. Germany and France have jointly banned all chick killing, and Italy has approved a law to ban the practice by the end of 2026.

While commercial egg producers in the UK have been criticised for failing to embrace technology to avoid the mass killing of chicks, retailers have also blocked moves to end the practice. However, some certified pasture-raised egg farms are taking steps to eliminate chick culling, and there is potential for farmers to avoid mass culling through breeding technology.

Maceration, gassing, cervical dislocation and asphyxiation are some methods of chick culling

Maceration, gassing, cervical dislocation, and asphyxiation are some methods used for chick culling. The method used depends on several factors, including the number of chicks being culled, the capacity and size of the farm, and the reason for culling. Maceration is a common practice within the egg industry and is used as a means of dispatching day-old male chicks, which are considered byproducts due to their inability to lay eggs. The process involves placing the chicks on a conveyor belt that ends in a large grinder, into which the chicks fall and are torn apart. Maceration is often considered more humane than carbon dioxide asphyxiation in western countries as death occurs immediately or within a second. It is the primary method used in the United States, Belgium, India, and the foie gras industry in France.

Gassing is another method used for chick culling, which involves stunning and then killing the chicks using carbon dioxide. Gassing is the only method used in Switzerland, Spain, and Belgium, and is also employed in the UK and Canada, alongside maceration. Gassing is often considered more humane than maceration. However, animal welfare advocates argue that current practices surrounding chicken slaughtering, including gassing, are unethical and involve the unnecessary exploitation and killing of sentient beings.

Cervical dislocation is a method of culling used when only a few birds are being killed at a time. It consists of snapping a chicken's spinal cord and is considered humane when performed by trained personnel. In the UK and the EU, only birds under 3 kilograms can be culled using this method.

Asphyxiation, or suffocation, is another method of chick culling, which can be achieved by filling the cages with foam. However, research has shown that birds killed using foam take longer to stop moving and produce more stress hormones than those killed using other methods like carbon dioxide exposure. Asphyxiation is the common method used in Spain.

The UK is blocking moves to end the killing of male chicks

Respeggt, a German service provider of in-ovo egg sexing, uses its patented Seleggt process to identify and prevent the hatching of male chicks. This technology can determine a chick's sex within 3-13 days of incubation, allowing farmers to repurpose the male eggs for other uses. However, only one small-scale poultry farm in the UK is using Respeggt's technology, with larger operations failing to embrace readily available technology to avoid the mass killing of chicks.

The industrial-scale culling of unwanted chicks is a common practice worldwide, with 330 million males slaughtered by crushing or gassing each year in Europe. The UK accounts for 29 million of these deaths. The industry has no use for cockerels that cannot lay eggs or be fattened up quickly enough to be sold for meat. However, it is possible for farmers to avoid mass culling through breeding technology already in use in France and Germany.

The killing of male chicks has been labelled as unethical and unnecessary by animal welfare advocates and rights activists. They argue that it is wrong to exploit and kill sentient beings for food production. With the development of new technologies, there is a growing movement to end chick culling in the UK and beyond. However, until consumer demand changes and retailers embrace these technologies, the blocking of moves to end the killing of male chicks in the UK will likely continue.

In-ovo sexing can prevent male chicks from hatching

In the UK, 29 million male chicks are slaughtered every year. This is a widespread practice in the egg industry, as male chicks cannot lay eggs and are usually less suited for meat production. This practice has raised ethical concerns about the treatment of animals within industrial farming.

In-ovo sexing is a technological innovation that can be used to address this issue. It involves determining the sex of an embryo before it hatches, allowing farmers to remove male eggs. This method can be achieved through various techniques, including optical technologies such as spectroscopy, AI-powered imaging, and MRI scans. These methods are contactless and free from the risk of bacterial infection, which is present in invasive procedures.

In-ovo sexing has been hailed as a pivotal advancement in the poultry industry, offering a way to avoid the mass culling of male chicks. It also provides economic benefits by automating the chick-sexing process, reducing labour costs, and creating potential revenue streams from the sale of culled eggs for alternative purposes.

In 2024, the UK government's Animal Welfare Committee recommended banning chick culling, although this is not yet legally binding. Germany, France, and Italy have successfully outlawed chick culling, with Italy planning to implement a ban by 2026. These countries have encouraged other EU member states to follow suit.

The adoption of in-ovo sexing technology in the UK has been met with some resistance, with UK supermarkets and retailers blocking moves to end the killing of male chicks. However, some companies, such as Respeggt, have been trying to enter the UK market and promote eggs that do not contribute to chick culling.

The killing of male chicks is considered unethical and unnecessary

The killing of male chicks, also known as chick culling, is a common practice in the industrialised egg production industry. It involves the separation and killing of male chicks that are deemed redundant and worthless by the industry. However, this practice is increasingly being recognised as unethical and unnecessary.

The primary justification for chick culling is the economic value of male chicks. Male chickens, or cockerels, do not lay eggs and are not typically used for meat production due to their slower growth rate. As a result, the egg industry considers them to have no economic value and deems them unnecessary. This perception of male chicks as worthless has led to the brutal killing of billions of chicks each year through violent methods such as shredding, burning, crushing, and drowning.

The ethical concerns surrounding chick culling arise from the unnecessary exploitation and killing of sentient beings. Animal welfare advocates and animal rights organisations argue that it is wrong to exploit and kill chicks simply because they are not profitable. They emphasise that the current practices of chick culling, which often involve extreme cruelty and suffering, are unacceptable and must be prohibited. Additionally, the deception within the egg industry, portraying itself as humane while engaging in these cruel practices, further underscores the unethical nature of chick culling.

The development of alternative methods, such as in-ovo sexing, provides a viable solution to end the unnecessary killing of male chicks. In-ovo sexing involves determining the sex of the embryo before hatching, allowing for the removal of male eggs from incubation. This approach has gained traction in countries like Germany, France, and Italy, which have introduced or pledged to introduce bans on chick culling. These countries have recognised the unnecessary nature of chick culling and have taken steps to implement more ethical practices.

Despite the availability of alternative technologies, the UK continues to lag behind in addressing this issue. While some certified pasture-raised egg farms are taking steps to eliminate chick culling, the majority of UK retailers and supermarkets are reluctant to embrace these changes. This resistance to change perpetuates the unnecessary killing of approximately 29 million male chicks annually in the UK. It is essential for stakeholders, policymakers, and consumers to recognise the unethical nature of chick culling and advocate for the adoption of more humane and sustainable practices.

Frequently asked questions